I have been chasing down a strange noise and need some advice/suggestions. Idling in park with the A/C on the car makes a noise that can best be described as a heat shield rattling and a whine. I have replaced the idler pulley, water pump and listened to the alternator and compressor with the old screwdriver to your ear trick and can't find it. With the A/C off, it still makes a rattling noise but its hard to locate. I have watched the crank pulley and its as solid as a rock. All I can say is that it seems like its coming from the upper front part of the engine.