You can type here any text you want

Driving on ice strategy (long story)

Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!

turbojimmy

Supporting Member
Joined
May 26, 2001
Messages
5,560
I use the word 'driving' loosely. My car had basically become a sled. But here’s the deal: driving to work this morning in my usual morning daze, I took my normal route. This route takes me down the steepest, most winding path down the mountain that I live on. It was raining, but it had been snowing and sleeting all night and the mountain road was totally covered in ice with water running over top of it. The sides of the road were plowed snow.

It wasn’t until I reached the descent that I snapped out of my fog and realized that I had made a poor decision in taking this route, and at that point there was no turning back. There was no way to turn the car around and even if there were there’s no way I could make it back up. The problem was that there was a pickup truck w/ a plow spun out across the road on the first, steep and blind corner. I saw the Jimmy in front of me get all bent out of shape as soon as his brake lights came on. Seeing this, I lightly hit my brakes but I immediately got the ABS working. The Jimmy came to a clumsy stop in the snowy shoulder (the only way to get traction) and I did the same. I knew there would be trouble because there were at least 2 cars coming down the hill behind me and they weren’t going to see me until it was too late.

Sure enough, a RAV 4 came up behind me and immediately went into a spin once he saw I was stopped. He was coming at me fast, and sideways, so I rolled (slid) up as far as I could to give him room. Once he hit the snowy shoulder he stopped.

So there we were. Jimmy, my Caddy, the RAV 4 and who knows how many other cars behind us peering down this steep road watching the guy in the 4WD pickup literally spin his way, albeit slowly, down the hill.

Once the pickup cleared out of the way, the Jimmy ventured down but chickened out at turn #2 and pulled up into someone’s driveway (actually he just sort of slid into someone’s driveway and parked it).

Seeing this, I waved the RAV 4 around me to plot my strategy. He put his window down, as did I, and we wished each other the best of luck. He went down quite a bit faster than I would have but in a somewhat controlled manner. He put his right wheels into the plowed snow, which I would find out later was littered with boulders since at that point you’ve really left the roadway. This strategy worked well for the RAV 4 until turn #3. At turn #3 it gets even steeper but it does straighten out a bit. It’s banked all wrong though and he took the turn sideways and nearly hit the guardrail.

With traffic piling up behind me I had little choice but to try the same thing the RAV 4 did. I put the right front tires into the snow for traction and slowly ventured down the hill. Putting the tires in the snow helped a little but at the exit of turn #2 I hit a boulder that was submerged in the snow. Luckily, I think, the car rode up on it starting behind the right front tire. I heard it rake along the floorboard until my right rear tire jumped up over it. This shot the car out of the snowy shoulder and onto the skating rink.

At this point my foot is in the brake and all 4 tires are locked up and I’m sliding down the hill. There’s no stopping me now – I was totally out of control. I wanted to see what would happen if I let off the brake but it was so steep I was afraid that it would get going too fast and make matters worse. All I could do was let gravity take its course. I slid through the remainder of turn #2 sideways across the road (thankfully no one was dumb enough to try to come UP the hill). I had the wheels cut all the way to the left trying to counter steer but it was no use. All 4 tires still locked up, the weight of the engine pulled the car back around the other way like a pendulum. Now I’m sliding sideways facing the other way. Until now this has pretty much been in slow motion, however it was at this point that the car started to pick up an uncomfortable rate of speed – again with all 4 tires locked up. I don’t know if it would have been better to let off the brake at this point to see if I could steer it at all, but I didn’t. As the guardrail approached the tires started to make a grinding noise against the pavement which meant that they were finding traction. The car began to straighten out. I let off the brakes and the stability control realized what was happening and intervened. It helped a little and I was out of danger and down to a less steep, straight part of the hill.

I couldn’t help but notice that the Neon behind me fared much better. Though he clearly wasn’t in control, he wasn’t in a 4-wheel lockup like I was. I could tell he had winter tires on the car, though. I'm on Pirelli P-Zero Neros which are semi-high performance tires but still technically 'all season'.

I checked the car out once I got to the garage at work and there’s no cosmetic damage – wheels look good, rocker molding is good. I need to take a look underneath when I get home tonight.

So when you find yourself with literally zero traction, on a steep hill, on a corner, what’s the best thing to do? Stay on the brakes and hope it gets stopped so you can sort it out or let off the brakes and hope that once the wheels are turning that you can find some traction?

Jim
 
Deja vu. I had a 4x4 truck 5 years ago, went over a small hill to a slight downgrade with a stop sign at the bottom. Just over the hill, traffic was backed up 8 deep at the stop sign shortening my stopping distance by 100' easy. I quickly found out the road was ice under snow. As I fishtailed and pumped the brakes simultaneously, I knew I could not stop in the distance available and I was fishtailing wildly (30 degree swings). In a moment of inspiration I moved into the other lane and continued my slide. Oncoming traffic saw me and fortunately did not enter the intersection nor my newly commandeered lane. I came to a stop about halfway beside the last car in the stop sign line. It was a real weenie shrinker.
 
I think I know what road you're talking about Jim. ;) That road sucks when it's dry and sunny.

Yes it sucked - it's Mountain Road and it is tricky even when it's dry and sunny. In my 20-something years of driving I've never been in such a hopeless situation. I was at a dead stop with my foot on the brake and I felt the car getting dragged down the hill. There was no steering or other means of controlling where the car went. That's why I wonder if I had actually let off the brake if it would have helped. The car would have gone much faster but would I have been able to steer it on the ice? I'm thinking I was pretty much screwed either way.

I was fortunate in that I really didn't hit anything other than that rock and there's no cosmetic damage. That pickup truck was bouncing off of everything like a pinball. The cops really didn't want to do anything about it but they should have blocked off the top of it to keep stupid people like me from going down it. It simply was not traversable.

Jim
 
Similar thing happened to me a few weeks back during a snow storm. I left work around 10pm and for some reason the city trucks hadn't even started to plow yet (it had been snowing for hours).

The entire drive home was fine because the streets get cleared enough just by constant Chicago traffic, but then there's the curvy stretch of road that goes through a forest preserve.

Making all this worse is that I knew a kid in high school who drove stupidly fast down this road during wet conditions, slipped into oncoming traffic, and died, so I always have that on my mind coming down this road.

With that in mind, I didn't want to be near oncoming traffic, so I took the far lane closest to the trees. The center lane seemed a little cleaner like more cars had been driving in it, but I still wanted to be away from oncoming traffic.

Took it really slow and careful the entire time, the one person next to me was driving faster and luckily passed me. A split second after they pass me, I feel my front wheels grab a rut in the snow and start to turn me left, towards oncoming traffic. I'm hardly even moving at this point, maybe 10-15mph. Here comes the "slow motion" effect. I'm waiting and waiting for the front end to kick back around. But it doesn't. Suddely the rear of the car kicks out and adds momentum to the spin. Before I know it I pull a full 180 and end up in the center lane.

Luckily the one person behind me was far enough back and was paying enough attention to see me spin out, and they slowed to a stop. Even luckier, oncoming traffic had been waiting at a red light at the other end of the forest and was only starting to approach as I spun out. I pulled quick (embarassed) J-turn and continuted on my way.

I was pretty mad. If I had been driving like a moron I would have deserved it. But I was being the most cautious person on that road at the time. I can only chalk it up to the fact that the snow was piled up more in the lane that I chose.

As far as what you're "supposed" to do in a situation like that, I think it's all just theory and you can't count on anything to save you 100% of the time. Pumping the brakes is better than just laying on them, especially if the ABS doesn't realize that you're sliding. At that point, you have to become the ABS, and you have to let your tires free to try to gain traction. If the ABS isn't pulsating and you aren't pumping the brake, then the wheels are just going to stay locked. I understand your concern that you didn't want to gain speed by releasing the brakes, but you only have to let them up for a split second to let the tire spin a little bit and try to bite the road. You won't have control of a car until your tires are moving at the same speed as the road. Having a tire dead still while sliding gives you the least chance of gripping. If you let the tire move and roll with the road, it has a better chance of catching.

All the ABS and traction-control in the world won't help you if the systems don't realize that you're slipping.
 
All the ABS and traction-control in the world won't help you if the systems don't realize that you're slipping.

Yeah in retrospect I probably should've let off the brakes to alert the electronic nannies that there was a problem. For all they knew I was sitting at a stoplight. Once I finally did let off the brakes the stability control tried to fix things. I'm not sure if it would have been effective earlier or not.

Jim
 
The magical E-brake.

With all the snow we had earlier in the week, I found myself driving down a hill using my ebrake and driving/steering with the motor. It's an 03 Regal so I had to disable traction control for this drive. The joys of a steep mountain like drive. The road crews weren't out in time to treat the road, we all got to play and soil ourselves.
 
So when you find yourself with literally zero traction, on a steep hill, on a corner, what’s the best thing to do? Stay on the brakes and hope it gets stopped so you can sort it out or let off the brakes and hope that once the wheels are turning that you can find some traction?

Jim


In the situation you had...say a prayer, go for it and clean the poop out of your pants when its over.:biggrin:
 
-That pickup truck was bouncing off of everything like a pinball.-

That's the only way to do it. :D

Best advise is just to stay away from Mountain Rd. in the snow. However, there seems to be something that draws people to it in bad weather. It must be the challenge.
 
I was told several years ago to only use the e-brake, which just brakes the back wheels. That keeps the front wheels from locking up and gives the best chance to keep some steering control. Locked up wheels don't do you any good when it comes to controlling the car. Of course, where I live, I don't get too many chances to try this theory out. :)

John
 
Those situations where you are not really in control are the worst.

I was in the same type of situation once about 35 years ago. I was trying to negotiate a hill that ended at a crossroad. The problem was that the crossroad paralleled a very deep canal. I'm sliding down this road/hill/skating rink ever so slowly but can't stop and there are no shoulders just frozen grass and then embankments. I try to use the embankments to stop the car but the car just ricochets off them and continues on. As I approach the T intersection and contemplate jumping from the car before it goes into the water (it is 2:00 AM, sleeting and no one around for 5-6 miles) I get this brilliant idea to try and hit one of the two telephone poles across the intersection before the canal. I don't want hit head on and am also afraid I might miss them meaning I would not have enough distance to then jump out so I let off the brakes, cut the wheel and gas it. So I do that and get the car sideways passenger side first in case I need to jump and cut the wheels back and lock the wheels so I'm now sliding sideways as I cross the intersection (no other fools out except yours truly) and gently hit and come to a stop very softly against both poles, one at each fender with virtually no damage to my old 61 Chevy Biscayne. I work the car away from them and park for a few minutes to collect my sanity, thank God and then go home very, very slowly.

Mikey
 
Those situations where you are not really in control are the worst.

I was in the same type of situation once about 35 years ago. I was trying to negotiate a hill that ended at a crossroad. The problem was that the crossroad paralleled a very deep canal. I'm sliding down this road/hill/skating rink ever so slowly but can't stop and there are no shoulders just frozen grass and then embankments. I try to use the embankments to stop the car but the car just ricochets off them and continues on. As I approach the T intersection and contemplate jumping from the car before it goes into the water (it is 2:00 AM, sleeting and no one around for 5-6 miles) I get this brilliant idea to try and hit one of the two telephone poles across the intersection before the canal. I don't want hit head on and am also afraid I might miss them meaning I would not have enough distance to then jump out so I let off the brakes, cut the wheel and gas it. So I do that and get the car sideways passenger side first in case I need to jump and cut the wheels back and lock the wheels so I'm now sliding sideways as I cross the intersection (no other fools out except yours truly) and gently hit and come to a stop very softly against both poles, one at each fender with virtually no damage to my old 61 Chevy Biscayne. I work the car away from them and park for a few minutes to collect my sanity, thank God and then go home very, very slowly.

Mikey

Wow, I almost soiled my shorts just reading that. I can just imagine how you felt.
 
Back
Top