There shouldn't be a difference....BUT....I only buy my gas from MAJOR gas stations (ex: Mobil, Sunoco). The dumpy little stations can have old tanks that let water/dirt in. Or they can be rip off's and try to push low octane for the premium price(even though illegal). I live in Western New York state, and arounds here Indian reservations are common. They do not have to pay state taxes, so they offer cheaper gas. BUT....they are not regulated by the state, so they can be selling anything from low octane to urine. I do not trust them. A friend of mine got a nice tank of watery gas from them. I also know of someone that got muddy gas from them. My friend works at a dealer and dropped a tank that was full of mud on the bottom. The user swore by cheap Indian gas......atlleast until then.