Well after learning new replacements were not available, I took a trip to Autozone to see what they had laying around.
I bought plastic bumper stripper, primer and paint. I did one fenderwell yesterday and it turned out very nice. As for how durable it will be...don't know, we'll see I guess.
Duplicolor maked the products and they should be easy to find. Until new ones become available (if), this may be a solution.
Follow the diresctions closely and take your time. Good luck.