Update, after pulling the main cap, the previous owner had a new rear main seal installed, but did not know if it was a neoprene. It is a neoprene, but they did use the side seals that came with the rear main seals, not the RTV. I am guessing that is why I had the bad leak. Also the sealant used along the sides of the main cap appears to be a yellow tinted silicon or something, not the black RTV.
Anyone with more experience with the rear main seals, please comment. This is the first time I have done this type of work. PaulRV6 and I need some pointers on the side seals.