momau3..howdy dude. I've been in the States for a while now, so no "secret" stuff for me.
You're not the infamous "Baghdad Bob" and formerly employed as the Iraqi Minister of Information are you?
Nope, haven't hung myself yet.
The Lower your torque RPM peak is, the better it is for racing and launching.
Ok. Why don't you go race a diesel? I mean really....what could be better that 500 lb/ft torque @ 2000 rpm? The answer is simple....its at only 2000 rpm, meaning that 500 lb/ft torque monster is only putting out 190 HP.
Assuming of course that U have the traction to utilize this torque. It is correct in that launching is everything in ¼ mile time. For every 0.1 sec U pick up in 60' time, your overall ET will pick up 0.15-0.20 sec. The torque does U no good if it goes into burning rubber.
Agreed. No rocket science there.
There is no simple answer or formula - there R 10 different ways to set up any given car. What U gain on the lower end, U will typically lose on the upper end, so things need to be balanced. Lotsa guys will go w a high (numerical) rear end ratio to get more torque down low and improve their launch. But then they may be over the HP peak at the top end and lose some there.
They may, or they may not. As a general rule of thumb, going through the traps ~800 rpm above HP peak is best for ET. Going through the traps nearer the HP peak will produce a better MPH. I like ET, and gear accordingly.
A Hi revving engine w a Hi torque peak can work
LOL. Ya think? Are you familier with NHRA Pro Stock? How high do you think their torque peaks are? What do you think they make more of - peak torque or peak HP? Do you think they "work"?
but then he will need a very Hi RPM Stall T convertor and perhaps a Transbrake.
Correct.
Then he always has to keep his RPM's up because he has no low end torque, so he will also have to raise his shift points.
Ok. In this hypothetical situation, is the idea to go fast, or keep the rpm down?
Such a car will be a Dog on the street.
Bologna. It might not "feel" good because you have to keep the rpm up to make good power, but it doesn't lose power or potential (assuming traction) just because it is on the street.
This is typically what the Ricers have to do to get any power.
Thank you. I'll have my DOHC 4.6L Uncle Ben's with a bit of butter, please.
this guy named lingenfelter seems to think that a street motor that makes most of its torque in the mid-range is ideal
You will get no arguement from me that a street car will feel much better with more mid-range power than upper rpm power. Most street cars are tuned for such. However, that does not make it faster.
( torque being more important than hp)
Ok. Let me get you a torque curve and you determine the shift points and finish line rpm. Fair enough? Unfortunately, I don't have a pic of just the torque curve. However, please determine optimum shift point from this dyno graph using ONLY the torque curve. Then please explain how you did it. Just get close. If you like, assume a 3/4 shift with 1.34 and 1.00 tranny gears.
http://members.cox.net/bobcosby/cobra/images/tkosae.jpg
he also said "torque plays a major role in street car acceleration
See above statement. You cannot seperate the two.