You could have leaks on the line leading to your boost gauge. This is typical from gauges installed many years ago. Understand that a small leak will make the gauge read less. As not 100% of the pressure is applied to the nipple on the back of the gauge. Those clear plastic lines start to break down after a few years.. ozone.. heat.. etc.
MAP are usually very accurate. This is why I never T into the line feeding the MAP sensor. Becuase any breach to the MAP it wont respond correctly.
My preset setting on all Buick controllers is the same. 7 psi or 2.2volts dc. If its activating at 5 according to your gauge, You have air leaks.