I have never in over 50 years of running high HP street/strip cars and high HP boats had a mechanical fuel pump failure that left me stranded. But I have had several electric pumps leave me walking, or swimming!
Why? Mechanical pumps are driven at engine rpm, so at low speeds/rpms, the pumps aren't doing much work. The electrics on the other hand, don't know what the engine speed or load is, so they are running wide open, full bore ALL OF THE TIME! They are puking their guts out making max pressure and flow all of the time! Even at idle!
Replace them, often! Once a year anyway, sell the old one to a race car guy that doesn't drive the car except once a week, or less at the track. It will last him for years!
The OEMs have solved these wear and fuel heating issues by pulse width modulation of the pumps supply amperge to drop pressure and volume in low load situations.
Until someone, MSD? Comes up with one of these modulation units for us, pump replacement is our only option.
Someone, perhaps MSD, had a resistor based unit that dropped pump voltage and current to carburated electric pumps, about 15/20 years ago. I had one on my blown BBC, 9 second Nova back in the 90s. Those worked in a carburated situation because carbs have float bowls to keep the flow constant pretty much regardless of fuel pressure. A full throttle switch bypassed the resistor stack at WOT. This won't work with FI. A Hobbs switch in the manifold could be used to shut off one of the double pumper pumps, but the main pump would still wear quickly. AND, if the system croaked, so would your engine!
Perhaps one of our computer ECM gurus might work on this! To my knowlege, the oem modulator systems are built into the ECM, and not capable of stand alone operation, nor capable of modulation of the current requirements of our large pumps.
Food for thought from the
TIMINATOR