I did not have any issues with my idle when my MAF went out. It did not trip any code either. When I unplugged it, the Check Engine Light lit up. There was NO DIFFERANCE in idle (which was fine) or under load with it unplugged. Two other people including a mechanic thought it was ignition related. Replaced with a known good MAF and discovered that it was my MAF all along.
I have gone through 4 bad MAF in the past two months and while I'm no expert I have determined 2 main issues.
Issue #1 terrible idle and car will barely run. This can be caused by a fried maf sensor or in the case of one of my maf's one of the resistor chips inside cracked. Diagnosis for this is unplug the maf and if the car idles better and runs somewhat normal then the MAF was the issue. Surprisingly the car did not throw a maf sensor code. I had 2 maf's with this issue. The reason I'm close to positive his maf isn't bad is because his OP says his car had an idle issue and unplugging the sensor didn't change the idle. Your problem is something I have experienced as well and this is what I learned on another sign of a maf that is not functioning correctly.
Issue #2 calibration of the MAF. GN maf's require a specific calibration and two of the MAF's I have tried had this issue. Your car will idle fine and will cruise around town just fine, however when you go wot the car will buck horribly like you're out of fuel, or like the car is hitting the rev limiter. Unplugging the maf will not cause the the idle to improve as there was nothing wrong with the idle to begin with , nonetheless if you unplug the maf you will notice a difference when the boost kicks in, however the best way I have learned to discover the issue in this case is to check the MAF readings
at WOT with the sensor plugged in.
Disclaimer "I would not recommend going wot with maf unplugged." If the wot maf readings are 200+ then your maf is good, however in my case the MAF readings were only reaching 67 which shows there was an issue with the calibration of the 2 maf's that had this issue.
Cliff Notes
1. Bad maf- Extremely rough idle, popping and backfiring, and car will barely run. Unplug maf see if it fixes the idle.
2. Bad calibration on a good maf- Good idle, fine around town, and wot MAF readings with the sensor plugged in are way below 200 possibly around 60-70
P.S. I'm hard headed and just bought another stock maf today bringing the tally to #5, wish me luck with this one guys.