i have had very good luck with the felpro blue rubber gaskets that don't have the frame in them. The key is to make sure that the pan rails and everything is completely free of oil. use a bunch of brake cleaner on them. also you can't over tighten the oil pan the factory had the little tits on the pan just for that reason so you can't over tighten the pan and bust the gaskets. you may simply be not tightened the bolts tight enuff.
I have never liked the rubber pan gaskets. They always seem to tear, especially if installing under the car. I torque the pan bolts (with a cork gasket WITH a light coat of Ultra-Black on BOTH sides) to German torque. Gute-n-tight. After torquing literally millions of bolts, I only use a torque wrench on head, main, and rod bolts. (and sometimes air cleaner wing nuts ) I rarely have a leak with a cork gasket and a light coat of silicone. That is what I have been doing for about 8 years. Valve covers leaking.................Is there such a thing as a dry valvecover on a Buick?
guess i'll pick up a Fel Pro cork gasket and be done with it. I normally use the cork gaskets for everything but i decided this time to try the rubber over steel gasket. Thats what i get for trying to "upgrade".
I did rubber on the TTA and GN 2 years ago...the GN started leaking within a few months and went with cork the next time and its been good ever since.
The TTA has been fine for 2 years, but just this week...a huge oil spot under it after I moved it out of the garage...its leaking like a seive all the sudden.
Fel-Pro does NOT have a cork gasket. Get one from Fullthrottle or another vendor. Detroit, Corteco, and ROL are the only ones that make a cork gasket. (that I know of) Not sure if Duttweiler has one still. His was top notch, very thick.
I used a felpro blue rubber gasket, bought a inch/pound torque wrench cleaned everything real good. I took my time and sneaked up on the torque final setting.... At first no leaks, 4 weeks later I notice that it is ripped, I'm going with a cork gasket next time.