Well the stock gauge was never accurate in the first place, then considering the stock wastegate actuator is 12psi all by itself you probably need to take out all of the MBC screw and start over.
I'm assuming you don't have the stock solenoid in play here and you have the MBC hosed like ......
Compressor fitting to bottom of MBC
90 degree MBC fitting going to Wastegate
If you pull out all of the MBC screw (meaning it's barely threaded in there) the psi should be about 12psi. Now if I remember correctly, the factory gauge is off like 2psi so this might look like 14psi or the 15psi light barely flickers.
Here's an easy way to see if the factory boost gauge is accurate, just run a hose from the compressor fitting to the wastegate actuator. That should open gradually and achieve 12psi of boost. If your factory gauge shows something higher, you know it's not accurate.