Try STONER brand, "More Shine Less Time". It is an aerosol can. Can be wiped down shorty after spraying for not such a gloss finish. Or leave alone and let it dry for a gloss finish. Great for the plastic fenderwells, air dams, inner fenderwells, etc.... I use a product line for my detailing business called Distinctive Details. Their product for this type application is called "Ultra Shine"
I have used Eastwoods "Chassis Black" to coat my undercarriage. It can be bought in Aerosol or paint. I like the quart can and put it on with a brush. With a good brush it goes on really evenly. You also do not have to worry about taping everything off and covering the whole car like you would with an aerosol. You can then use the above mentioned products to give it that wet look. You have lots of options here, this is just what I like.