The BOLD part is the WHOLE problem here guys, the correct answer is NO, Dennis Kirban was making billet pulleys before RJC was in business, Just like girdles and other items that were made long before he was around. The original pulleys he came out with looked exactly like the Kirban ones. Do some homework the truth is out there. Just becase a guy make a part it does not mean another guy can't make it too that is the way free enterprise works. None of these items are patentable.
Mike,
I could be wrong here and correct me if I am as this is passed on info over the years..
I think there is one thing being over looked here. I have heard that kirban only had one or just a couple pullies offered back then and Stopped selling them before RJC even came along and made them?? RJC made them as a larger set (More pieces)??
See the KEY here is STOPPED SELLING! before another vendor.. (Reflects that the original vendor No Longer has intrest in offering the said product)
EXAMPLE: I Have made/improved on products that ATR used to make/sell BUT they are no longer in buisness and there products are no longer available to the public so to me there is no competing against them in any way, shape or form. When a vendor/company DROPS a product and no longer makes or sells it Wouldn't it be considered fair game? I would think so..
My thought on patends:
Patends are useless if items get shipped to China to be made so why would someone spend all the cash involved in one when it's not a world wide patend?
Secondly, all one needs to do to get around a pattend is change it by so much. There again, If someone really wants to make it They can and do!!
That covers the MAKING of the product out of our state, NOW "SELLING" a copied product here that had a pattend or pattend pending title originally is a totally different story!!
After seeing this issue erupt over china products I got to thinking, Do I sell any china products? Well I went to my site and looked at Every item I sell and NOT ONE is made in china!! EVERYTHING we sell is made and assyembled right here in the U.S.A and I was pretty proud of that..
I guess people are just going to have to accept this and that this will be around for a long time to come....
Peace!
SW.