The billet cams are stronger,of course. The cast roller will do everything you want. The most important thing is to have enough spring pressure to make sure the lifter never moves away from the cam lobe. If the lifter is allowed to bounce,the resulting reunion will chip away at the lobe. The billet cam is more tolerant of this situation. Remember that if your setup is fine at 5,800,the lifter might bounce when you hit 6,000. Make sure you have enough spring to survive severe tire spin or over revving from a no shift condition.