There's no comparison between a Ford 9" and a 12 bolt! Ford 9" is much better/stronger then a 12 bolt. The center section is one piece. No rear-end girdle needed. Everything stays intact. I would never use a 12 bolt. May as well stay with the 10 bolt that came with the car.... Agree the D. locker is a rattle. Good rear, or so I'm told. Just didn't want to deal with the noise they make.
I am also in the market to buy either a 12 bolt or a 9" right now. the problem i was having with a fully built 8.5 was the small axle tubes bending forward. the 12 and the 9 both have larger tubes . i like the 12 for its efficiency and it is stock appearing. 9's get expensive when you start pricing a strong enough center section.