Craig,
I do not disagree with your statements. My personal experience has shown that a .5 pph per horsepower is a pretty good number.
Interestingly enough, a year ago I had similar questions about how to use the nitrous tables, and called several "big name" nationally known engine builder/tuners (this was before I found this board!). Their consistent recommendation for a 100-150 shot was to start with a 1 to 1 ratio of fuel pph to horsepower, and lean out rom there. Also, all three that were willing to talk recommended against running closed loop.
I have since run the car several times with a 100 horse kit, and found no problems running closed loop, and have ended up at the .5 pph/hp number, so I'm not sure where they were coming from. I do remember that they were all very concerned about running lean, and not one voiced any concern about running too rich.
I have been following this forum for some time, and have great respect for your input, so now I feel lucky that I did not have a big "bang" running too rich. I can remember running strong with an indicated a/f of about 10:1, but am now running at about 11.5:1.
Thanks for your feedback.
Vince
PS. Was it bad form to answer a question directed at you? If so, I apologize.